Jump to content

solid Mahogany or Maple top...Agile


djchase7

Recommended Posts

  • Members

Is it just a matter of looks or personal preferance? Is there a noticible differance in feel or tone? I considering these:

 

http://www.rondomusic.net/al2000hsbf.html

 

or

 

http://www.rondomusic.net/al20003ts.html

 

I just can't justify spending too much money on an LP copy so the AD-3000 line is out. I want a cheap beater that I can thrash on with no regrets. This will be my first Agile, and I'm stoked to see if it lives up to all the hype. I've played many LPs studios and standards but I just cant justify the price. I'd rather buy another amp and a cheaper guitar that plays/sounds just as nice as the real thing.

 

am I crazy? or what? tell me what you think.

 

Current guitars:

Epi Casino

Peavey Falcon

Dano re-issue

Martin DC1

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Originally posted by djchase7

Is it just a matter of looks or personal preferance? Is there a noticible differance in feel or tone? I considering these:




or




I just can't justify spending too much money on an LP copy so the AD-3000 line is out. I want a cheap beater that I can thrash on with no regrets. This will be my first Agile, and I'm stoked to see if it lives up to all the hype. I've played many LPs studios and standards but I just cant justify the price. I'd rather buy another amp and a cheaper guitar that plays/sounds just as nice as the real thing.


am I crazy? or what? tell me what you think.


Current guitars:

Epi Casino

Peavey Falcon

Dano re-issue

Martin DC1

 

 

The top on the 2000 is 1/16", dso I don't think it will make much difference in tone. If you are staying within the 2000 line, I would go with the look you like. If you can swing it they have 2500s for $159. I have a DC blue flame - very nice guitar.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Originally posted by timmy210

Neither of those have maple tops, only maple veneers which are 1/16th thick. If you look at the AL comparison chart it tells you which models have maple tops and which dont.

 

 

I thought I read that the tops were "real Maple" as far as I know veneer is plastic not wood.

 

http://www.rondomusic.net/alspec.html

 

so...what is it? That chart only specifes grade of maple and thickness. It says nothing about veneer. Do you know Agile AL-2000 have veneer tops for a fact?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Originally posted by animl



The top on the 2000 is 1/16", dso I don't think it will make much difference in tone. If you are staying within the 2000 line, I would go with the look you like. If you can swing it they have 2500s for $159. I have a DC blue flame - very nice guitar.

 

 

dosen't seem like much of an improvment over the others (links above) only differance is the grade of top.

 

http://www.rondomusic.net/al2500hc.html

 

but it's soild anyways. what gives?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Originally posted by djchase7



I thought I read that the tops were "real Maple" as far as I know veneer is plastic not wood.




so...what is it? That chart only specifes grade of maple and thickness. It says nothing about veneer. Do you know Agile AL-2000 have veneer tops for a fact?

 

 

Veneer- To overlay or plate with a thin layer of wood or other material for outer finish or decoration; as, to veneer a piece of furniture with mahogany.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Originally posted by djchase7



I thought I read that the tops were "real Maple" as far as I know veneer is plastic not wood.




so...what is it? That chart only specifes grade of maple and thickness. It says nothing about veneer. Do you know Agile AL-2000 have veneer tops for a fact?

 

1/16 of an inch is a veneer.

This is a common technique in building furniture.

A real wood veneer is glued over a substrate(particle board or similar) to give the appearence of a finer wood.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Originally posted by markas214



Veneer- To overlay or plate with a thin layer of wood or other material for outer finish or decoration; as, to veneer a piece of furniture with mahogany.

 

 

oh... Now I know what Veneer is! WoW! I go down to home depot and ask for some...hummm....will it be wood or plastic....hummm.....I'm not talking furniture.

 

Veneer is plastic. Wood is wood. The act of "veneering" is what you have discribed. yes you can layer woods on top of each other and call that veneer, but what your really taling about is lamination.

 

I don't care to further discus vocabularies.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Originally posted by djchase7



oh... Now I know what Veneer is! WoW! I go down to home depot and ask for some...hummm....will it be wood or plastic....hummm.....I'm not talking furniture.


Veneer is plastic. Wood is wood. The act of "veneering" is what you have discribed. yes you can layer woods on top of each other and call that veneer, but what your really taling about is lamination.


I don't care to further discus vocabularies.

Don't go away mad just go away.:)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members
Originally posted by djchase7



oh... Now I know what Veneer is! WoW! I go down to home depot and ask for some...hummm....will it be wood or plastic....hummm.....I'm not talking furniture.


Veneer is plastic. Wood is wood. The act of "veneering" is what you have discribed. yes you can layer woods on top of each other and call that veneer, but what your really taling about is lamination.


I don't care to further discus vocabularies.

I guess you're just too stupid to realize veneer is a layer whether it be wood, plastic or whatever. Veneer has to be applied to a surface, hence the definition which was posted as informative but you obviously believed to be an insult. Grow up junior. Oh. two s' in discuss. Discribed is actually described. Lamination? Well never mind as it's obviously over your head.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

solid mahogany will sound darker - mids, than a mohogany with a maple top.

 

the veneer maple top btw - makes a lot of difference.

 

Forget the tobacoo sunburst for $129.00 though, get the Cherry Flame maple top for $159.00!! It's gorgeous and plays/sounds unbelievable!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Originally posted by markas214

I guess you're just too stupid to realize veneer is a layer whether it be wood, plastic or whatever. Veneer has to be applied to a surface, hence the definition which was posted as informative but you obviously believed to be an insult. Grow up junior. Oh. two s' in discuss. Discribed is actually described. Lamination? Well never mind as it's obviously over your head.

 

you don't have to be an ass. Call me jr. sure, I'm only 24. Well...I guess this is goodbye....I'm sad now. I'm gona cry....:wave:

 

obviously over my head..eh...must be too stupid to spell or to dumb to type. later dude.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Originally posted by blues_rocker

they dont sound or play like a gibson...my $.02

 

 

no - and they don't cost 1/10th the price - I own an Agile (a fine guitar in my opinion) and didn't have to spend the family fortune for a damn guitar...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Originally posted by jrfan


1/16 of an inch is a veneer.

This is a common technique in building furniture.

A real wood veneer is glued over a substrate(particle board or similar) to give the appearence of a finer wood.

 

Veneering was also popular because you could get predictable behavior out of the finished product.

It produces a much more stable table top oe whatever than solid woods do and they move less with changes in humidity.

In guitar making, It adds a new level of tone manipulation and mabye not for the better according to many who are much more knowlwgable than I on the subject.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

In woodworking ( and this includes guitars made of wood ) a veneer is the application of a thin layer of finish grade material to either an undesireable looking, manmade (plywood) or engineered ( particleboard...MDF...MDO ) substrate. Capping is the application of laminating 2 thick pieces together either of the same type or different types ( such as the 3000 3/4" maple "CAP"0. I doubt anyone can tell the difference in sound with a veneer finish vs non-veneer....however a cpped body will surely take on a different tone. Also some bodies use a laminated photo film of plastic to "simulate" a real expensive finish and bury it in a thick finish topcoat. And yes you can laminate with plastic such as melemine or with formica...a paper product. I have a 2800 and love it from a tone and construction point...just MHO

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Originally posted by spadoctor

In woodworking ( and this includes guitars made of wood ) a veneer is the application of a thin layer of finish grade material to either an undesireable looking, manmade (plywood) or engineered ( particleboard...MDF...MDO ) substrate. Capping is the application of laminating 2 thick pieces together either of the same type or different types ( such as the 3000 3/4" maple "CAP"0. I doubt anyone can tell the difference in sound with a veneer finish vs non-veneer....however a cpped body will surely take on a different tone. Also some bodies use a laminated photo film of plastic to "simulate" a real expensive finish and bury it in a thick finish topcoat. And yes you can laminate with plastic such as melemine or with formica...a paper product. I have a 2800 and love it from a tone and construction point...just MHO

 

 

Finally someone who knows what they are talking about! Basically I just want a guitar made of wood without a plastic top (some call it a veneer others call it worthless {censored}) The maple "cap" is what I'm looking for. I guess I call Rohndo and ask for one of a 200$ AL-3000! I can't wait.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Originally posted by jrfan


Don't go away mad just go away.
:)

 

I've been here longer then you...and didn't give a shit when they reduced my post count along with everyone else a while back. Dose it matter in life, how many post you've made? Why don't you go away? ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

The AL-2000 you want is a veneered top. It is wood.

The Agiles with the "caps" are 3000m and 3500 models.

ONLY. The rest are either all mahogany or mahogany with a maple veneer.

 

In woodworking (guitar making) veneer is a term that is associated with thin wood that is applied over a body. A Laminate or Photo Flame is different only in what is being attached. Same thing only not an actual piece of wood.

 

I doubt highly that you could tell the sound difference between a phot flame and a veneer but you would probably be able to tell a difference visualy from off angles.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...