Jump to content

Bag End 115 vs Mesa Engineering 115


txbass68

Recommended Posts

  • Members

 

I am considering either a used Bag End S15B-D or a Mesa Engineering PowerHouse 115. Which would you recommend? I can get them used for between $300 and $400.:poke: I will be playing Texas Country/ Southern Rock and Doom Metal.

 

 

The Mesa will have an s*%&-ton of more low end, can handle a lot of power and will also weigh about 20 lbs more IIRC. The Bad Ends are small cabs and are very middy, with a low end that declines very quickly. Bag Ends are neat cabs, but probably about the last choice for any music with "Doom" in the title.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Gotcha on the Doom part. Thanks for the input.:thu:

The Mesa will have an s*%&-ton of more low end, can handle a lot of power and will also weigh about 20 lbs more IIRC. The Bad Ends are small cabs and are very middy, with a low end that declines very quickly. Bag Ends are neat cabs, but probably about the last choice for any music with "Doom" in the title.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I wasn't aware that they changed drivers.

 

To my knowledge, only the VERY first Powerhouse designed cabs had EV drivers.

 

Mesa started to develop their own PH drivers in-house maybe a year later? Maybe a little more.

 

I had a 210 w/ the EV's in it, and honestly don't remember it being any night and day difference from current designs. And I've had a good many PH cabs over the years... ;)

 

The PH115 is a beast though. I loved it. Friggin' Mesa and their 215 @ 8 ohms designs!?!? Wtf, yo!! 2xPH115 would be {censored}in' sweet mang. :thu:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Well, I may just combine the Diesel with the Powerhouse in a road case and let it go.:) Thanks for you input guys.:thu:

To my knowledge, only the VERY first Powerhouse designed cabs had EV drivers.


Mesa started to develop their own PH drivers in-house maybe a year later? Maybe a little more.


I had a 210 w/ the EV's in it, and honestly don't remember it being any night and day difference from current designs. And I've had a good many PH cabs over the years...
;)

The PH115 is a beast though. I loved it. Friggin' Mesa and their 215 @ 8 ohms designs!?!? Wtf, yo!! 2xPH115 would be {censored}in' sweet mang.
:thu:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

The Mesa will have an s*%&-ton of more low end, can handle a lot of power and will also weigh about 20 lbs more IIRC. The Bad Ends are small cabs and are very middy, with a low end that declines very quickly. Bag Ends are neat cabs, but probably about the last choice for any music with "Doom" in the title.

 

+1

 

Unless, you want to cut through the Doom nicely. Then, Bag End. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

The Mesa will have an s*%&-ton of more low end, can handle a lot of power and will also weigh about 20 lbs more IIRC. The Bad Ends are small cabs and are very middy, with a low end that declines very quickly. Bag Ends are neat cabs, but probably about the last choice for any music with "Doom" in the title.

 

 

Oh, hell no!

 

B-D, 40 hz +/- 6 dbs. They also weigh about the same, with the BagEnd heavier by six pounds. The BagEnd is bigger, though, that the Powerhouse. 103db at 1w/1m. BagEnd should have much more lows that the Powerhouse.

 

Compare apples to apples. He is not looking at the S15-D. Two completely different creatures.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Oh, hell no!


B-D, 40 hz +/- 6 dbs. They also weigh about the same, with the BagEnd heavier by six pounds. The BagEnd is bigger, though, that the Powerhouse. 103db at 1w/1m. BagEnd should have much more lows that the Powerhouse.


Compare apples to apples. He is not looking at the S15-D. Two completely different creatures.

 

 

Ah, my mistake on the model. I doubt there would be a lot of difference in the lows though, I don't always trust low end specs like that though. The Mesa is still rated for 200 more watts.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Who needs more watts with better efficiency? 103 db at 1w/1m. Sounds noticably louder than 97 db at 1w/1m.

 

EDIT: I have TWO of these cabinets. I've never used both together except outdoors, with a Peavey Max700 head bumping it. Outstanding lows, and great mids and highs, too.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

How about the Mesa 1516? There is a guy with one for sell not from from my house. Could the handle the Doom Stuff alright?

 

 

It could, but I'm not a huge fan of the design.

It's heavier than a bitch, not that efficient and definitely not as killer as their 115 designs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

You said you have two of these cabinets. Which ones. The Bag End or the Mesa?

 

 

Who needs more watts with better efficiency? 103 db at 1w/1m. Sounds noticably louder than 97 db at 1w/1m.


EDIT: I have TWO of these cabinets. I've never used both together except outdoors, with a Peavey Max700 head bumping it. Outstanding lows, and great mids and highs, too.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

You said you have two of these cabinets. Which ones. The Bag End or the Mesa?

 

 

*looks over shoulder...logging in at work...*

 

 

Two S15B-D's. Very good cab. Very deep. Still plenty of highs and mids. I usually use them separately, one only, in a theater that holds 230+ without p.a. support. It fills the room with no problem and with little wattage.

 

I have used both outdoors, and it was heaven!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

OK, thanks. I might get it and try it out. If I do not like it I will just try and turn it for what I wined up paying for it.:thu: I am running it with the 700RB II.

 

*looks over shoulder...logging in at work...*



Two S15B-D's. Very good cab. Very deep. Still plenty of highs and mids. I usually use them separately, one only, in a theater that holds 230+ without p.a. support. It fills the room with no problem and with little wattage.


I have used both outdoors, and it was heaven!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...