Jump to content

Those terrible clips of pro singers


OldMattB

Recommended Posts

  • Members

I have seen several youtube-type clips of professional singers and raw audio where they just sound awful. I can't believe these people are really that bad!

 

Any sound pros know the answer? Are these singers just concentrating on synchronizing with a track and their dancing? Does tone correction equipment make being a superstar that easy (and deceptive)? Are they just rehearsing choreography and saving their pipes?

 

What gives?

 

oldMattB

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

yea some of them are really horrible- for example I am from bulgaria and in the Music Idol 2 here were really good live singers that were way better than the original so caller "proffesianal" "singers".I gues it is just that the celebrities don't focus too much on being that good because they can edit it and make it better...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

The Enrique Inglesias one is the reason for my post, but I have seen several artists doing this.

 

 

i thought that turned out to be a hoax, ...and it was some karoke dude instead.

 

i think enrique even went on a national tv show (letterman, maybe) and sang that song american idol audition style (no mic, no efx, no backing track), ..and everyone agreed it couldn't be him on that track.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

YIKES, I mean, I knew Britney wasn't the best singer ever, but that top clip!! HORRENDOUS! It sounds as if it's just a guide vocal while she's dancing.

 

The early clip is quite good...she needs more control of her developing voice, but it's a good voice, you can tell. I don't really know what happened there...she seemed to stop using most of her voice and her talent when she became popular and now just uses this nothing, sort of breathy voice which she then affects with techno stuff. What a waste.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

the spears "baby, one more time" intro seems the work of an imposter. note the vibe -- it's free form, maybe not susceptible to a click track, and therefore, not as easily lip synced. although she's no great singer, i've heard her sing live ballads, with good, yet imperfect vocals. pitch correction sounded non existent. i don't think a singer can sing at the good, yet

imperfect, level and then suck to the extent of the clip.

 

i don'y hear any/much of a chorusing/delay effect. i expect to hear that if the , because this is the effect produced when an artist sings over a recording of their own voice.

 

there's a linda mccartney live version video also. i suspect it's fake also.

 

the technology to record and distribute this audio -- it preceded youtube. yet these leaks are supposed to have recently surfaced? i doubt it.

 

the true audio may suck almost this much, but i detect fakery in the clips.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

i thought that turned out to be a hoax, ...and it was some karoke dude instead.

 

 

He spoke about it on Howard Stern once. He said is was basically a lip-synch performance, there were no (or catastrophically inadequate) monitors. He was just yelling the lyrics, emoting effort/feel, not even trying to sing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members
Enrique Inglesias is unfortunately a pretty damn good singer. Good voice + male model looks + charismatic yet humble personality = fame. Genetics is a bitch to the rest of us.

The only thing that is genetic bout this is looks, rest are developed. BTW, most models use lots of time on looks to stay models. So if you and I worked out an hour a day, got a tan, shaved and took a shower, we would appear decent too. Throw in a expensive suit and a Limo, and I bet we'd shine!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Natural metabolism, skin type, facial and body bone structure, hair type (and whether you lose it), are unfortunately genetic. But I agree, if the average person had the time and motivation to spend on their physical appearance/diet/nutrition the whole human race would be more attractive. Still doesn't mean wed look like brad pitt in his prime.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...