Jump to content

New Member with New Lyrics, Please critique


PromiseMeThis

Recommended Posts

  • Members

Thanks for the compliments guys. As soon as the bassist comes back I can probably record In fluid silence on acoustic (The bassist recordes all our stuff) I should have a badly done compulsion to be within the next week cause I recorded that for my final in Guitar class

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Let me say again if I haven't already, very well done. One thing that I wonder about, in the verse

 

The Days Have past

When we would fall a

Sleep together side by side

 

It reads as if Sleep is a separate entity. But to a listener it would come across as 'asleep'. Speaking of listening, I look forward to hearing them. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Originally posted by PromiseMeThis

Yeah I know the asleep thing is F'd up but I had to write it the way I sing it so I don't try to change it around and ruin the song. It's one of the great downsides of having musical A.D.D.

:)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Just finished recording "In Fluid Silence" acoustic style. We got my friend christina from another band called "As The Poets Affirm" to play some cello and do some singing. I apoligize in advance for the singing on my part, I'm sick with a cold and i made a few mistakes. The cold also contributes to me sounding generally unhealthy. You can here it at http://www.purevolume.com/promisemethis

Tell me what ya think

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

rarely do I hear emo singing done well i.e. Modest Mouse, Death Cab for Cutie. Generally this kind of nasally stuff is annoying and ruins an otherwise good song.

I'd suggest not trying so hard to sound like acoustic green day, or whatever it is you're going for.

 

The cello is great, the acoustic guitar needs some serious practice before recording.

 

I'd suggest ditching the male vocals and getting the girl to sing full time. I realize you've got a cold (lame excuse, why would you record with a cold?) but the vocals really stink.

 

I think you're songwriting is great and would like to hear it with the girl singing, especially for the "screamo". I don't know what that is really, but my imagination runs wild

:D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I recorded while sick cause there we promised to have something recorded for some folks within a couple days. That was 2 weeks before that was recorded. We lost our drummer a few weeks ago (booted him, half way thru recording another song) and were forced to record acoustic in order to keep our word. I play exclusively electric for the past 3 years, the only acoustic I have cost me $10 with very high action, thus giving some explanation for the sour notes in the intro. Thanks for your honesty cause people who know you generally try to sugar coat the truth. Hopefully I can get a copy of our other recorded song, Half of the Art (our resident net nazi wont let us post it and refuses to provide us with the site code) to show you the screamo type stuff which is unfortunately still on acoustic.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...