Man I understand some of your argument, but that blanket statement exposes you as a button pusher (that's what you do for a living huh?).
I've bought and installed pickups from DiMarzio, Duncan, GFS, BG Pups, Kinman, and Vintage Vibe. Out of all of those, the only pickups that have disappointed me have been from GFS, not to knock them. I have also had excellent results (ProTubes, FatBodies, and Dream 180's come to mind). The good have made up for the bad and I consider myself a satisfied customer overall.
But lumping boutique products with the rest in terms of quality and service is ludicrous...of course you probably wouldn't get along well with a pickup maker especially after you tell him how easy it must be to wrap wire around the magnets for a living.
That's just {censored}ing uncool.
I've been disappointed by pickups from a variety of makers, some much more prestigious than GFS.
They're all different. Saying BG or DiMarzio are better than GFS is like saying chocolate is better than than rocky road. Not better, different.
Well, I shouldn't say that. As simple as pickups are, you can do it wrong. I've played no-name import pickups that were absolutely terrible. But at the level of GFS and higher (ie more expensive), the pickups are all made "right" and it's just a matter of personal preference from that point on.