I haven't read this whole thread, so someone else may have said it...But, the scene used with the soldier was taken from an interview that appeared on a news show...Which would make it the property of said news show, correct? If so, if Moore bought the rights to air that scene from the news show, I don't see how this lawsuit has any ground. the soldier would have had to OK or sign agreements to air his interview with the news, thus it becomes their entity legally, I believe (copyrights and all that)...So, if Moore gets it from them, he's in the clear IMO.