Jump to content

A great melody first, then lyrics,(only) THEN 'vocals'


Mark Blackburn

Recommended Posts

  • Members

Ever hear of Oscar Levant? If you're under 60, probably not. He was a fixture in movie musicals including the best of them all (according to Tony Bennett) The Band Wagon. What he lacked in the way of movie star good looks, Levant made up for with his sardonic wit and piano playing prowess. His friend George Gershwin thought Oscar played the Rhapsody in Blue better than anyone

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

. . . and tell me, what street compares with Mott Street, in July?



My favorite Disney voice belonged to Sterling Holloway. You may not know his name but if you are 'of an age' his voice was as familiar to you as any relative's: Just off the top of my head Sterling gave voice to The Stork in Dumbo, the snake Kaa in The Jungle Book, the Cheshire Cat in Alice in Wonderland and the mouse

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

The Beatles' principal melodist (on ballads) knew he'd arrived as a composer when jazz artists began covering his best tunes, like "Yesterday." The year The Beatles recorded "Abbey Road" an up-and-coming guitar giant, George Benson recorded his Grammy-winning "The Other Side of Abbey Road" -- picking and singing all of the tracks of the original, in his inimitable style.


[His cover photo, mimicking the Beatles famously crossing Abbey Road London on foot (Paul barefoot!) had Benson holding a Guild electric guitar (the very model I owned!) and walking alone across a back street in New York.]


But my favorite of his Beatles covers is this one (for his "Tenderly" album of 20 years ago, backed by jazz giants like McCoy Tyner -- John Coltrane's last pianist -- and my favorite stand-up acoustic bass player, Ron Carter). But as always (here there and everywhere) it's all about "great melody first," isn't it?


 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p7fOLOa8KVQ

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Hey Mark... for someone so appreciative of music and who has the gift of being able to articulate your thoughts about music... maybe you can try your hand at commenting on some of our music. What say you?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

When the evenin' sun goes down . . .

the night life, ain't no good life . . .

but it's my life.


The first time Willie Nelson appeared on Late Night with David Letterman (a New Year's Eve show 20 years ago) he asked the Canadian-born band leader Paul Schaffer to provide a jazz arrangement, working with two country jazz musicians Willie brought along with him.


Willie left it to Letterman to research why he'd selected NIGHT LIFE. The king of flippant humor (where the joke is always presumed to have been made, where none actually exists) came 'this close' to asking Willie the right question

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Quote Originally Posted by Mark Blackburn

View Post

More than once in 50 pages here I've stated the personal belief that "the last great melody of the 20 was Billy Joel's (I Love You) JUST THE WAY YOU ARE.

 

I'm still trying to wrap my head around this statement, 50 pages later. cool.gif


For instance, I don't see at all why that Billy Joel melody is any better than this one.


 



I also think that Bee's most recent upload is as good as 90% of the songs posted in this thread. It is memorable (still played in my head hours after listening) and one that I am able to follow along with just a single listen without being too simplistic.


I've mentioned and posted a couple Radiohead tunes with exquisite melodies, so strong that you complete grasp the emotion despite Thom's tendency to slur his words.


Mark, what specifically is it about the melodies of these songs that make them better?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Satellite radio is playing a Winnipeg-born singer Kenny Colman's version of WHY SHOULD I CARE. I've spoken to Kenny, who worked at the same Bermuda radio-television station (ZBM) a decade before me, in the 60s about his fine interpretation of a sad and beautiful ballad -- that has yet to be uploaded to YouTube.


The only other cover of this song I've ever heard is Diana Krall's -- a hidden bonus track on one of her more recent albums; naturally there was no info on who wrote it. It took a while to determine it wasn't a song of the same name by Cole Porter. Turns out it was written by Dirty Harry -- another beautiful melody co-written by Clint Eastwood.


Finally, when I wasn't looking, someone's uploaded an attractive video of Diana Krall's interpretation, heard over the closing credits of the movie True Crime, which starred and was directed by Clint. Some guys have all the luck as well as talent, don't they?


 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kOAkbVDCC2g

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

It's the first nine notes, actually -- for my example of how this one could have been turned into a "riff tune." Most recent version is by my favorite Broadway singer of recent vintage, Harry Connick Jr. To my ears, Harry has the best tone & timbre and phrasing (breath control) of any male singer since Sinatra; I'd agree with the concise, informed "comment" from last summer that,


John Rait was a wonderful broadway performer with a great voice. Sammy Davis did his usual excellent work on his cover, Rosemary Clooney had the sweetest version. but this one by Harry is the the best ever. Harry sings? it like Sinatra would have, only better! Thanks omarov for posting this ultimate version of a standard.

rogerthornehill 1 year ago



 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

As it does most every hour, satellite radio channel 71 is playing a 'definitive' Ella Fitzgerald song: Ella's retire-the-trophy take on TO KEEP MY LOVE ALIVE.


It was the last song my all-time favorite melodist Richard Rodgers composed with his first great collaborator Lorenz (

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Every three or four songs on Siriusly Sinatra satellite radio is one by Frank: usually a classic, but occasionally a bit of fluff like the one playing right this minute -- CHERRY PIES OUGHT TO BE YOU.


You can tell by the sound it's a 'circa 1950' recording --a duet with Rosie Clooney on what sounds like a Cole Porter 'laundry list' song. Turns out it is

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Quote Originally Posted by Mark Blackburn

View Post

Every three or four songs on Siriusly Sinatra satellite radio is one by Frank: usually a classic, but occasionally a bit of fluff like the one playing right this minute -- CHERRY PIES OUGHT TO BE YOU.


You can tell by the sound it's a 'circa 1950' recording --a duet with Rosie Clooney on what sounds like a Cole Porter 'laundry list' song. Turns out it is

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Quote Originally Posted by LCK

View Post

Another often-forgotten fact: Frank Sinatra often picked mediocre (or worse) material.

 

When I think of 'worse' material from Frank, about the first thing that comes to mind is his version 'On the Road to Mandalay.' Not that the song is bad -- it isn't by a long way -- but I can hardly think of a worse mismatch of song and singer.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...