Which one do I sell?

[juice]

I'm wanting to pick up a Gretsch 5120 but need to sell something first. I have two acoustics and really need one only, so I am trying to decide which i should unload.

 

I have an Epi J-200 and a Seagull S6. I like them both equally. The Epi despite being a laminate top plays AWESOME, and the Seagull is good as well. I'm TORN!!!

 

Oh yeah, I have no case for the Seagull (Roadhouse gig bag) and I have a TKL hardshell case for the Epi which would probably make them equal as far as value i think.

[Dan Hall]

I'm wanting to pick up a Gretsch 5120 but need to sell something first. I have two acoustics and really need one only, so I am trying to decide which i should unload. I have an Epi J-200 and a Seagull S6. I like them both equally. The Epi despite being a laminate top plays AWESOME, and the Seagull is good as well. I'm TORN!!! Oh yeah, I have no case for the Seagull (Roadhouse gig bag) and I have a TKL hardshell case for the Epi which would probably make them equal as far as value i think.

Sell the Epi

[guitarist21]

I agree. If I were you I'd sell the Epi. Partially because I like Seagulls better, partially because I think that in a couple years, people will see that Seagulls have only gotten better with time and they'll probably be wiling to shell out a little more for them.

 

Ellen

[simplygoodmusic]

I disagree. Sure, if I didnt know either guitar, I'd say the epi...but your reaction shows me that you care more about the epi. Screw whether its laminate or not. A good guitar is a good guitar.

[JaLester]

I think you should sell the epi as well. I love my seagull and think they are amazing for their price. However if you want to sell the seagull, you will have have plenty of people interested. I think its easier to sell the 'gull instead of the epi. It's just a choice you got to make, but I would keep the seagull.

[bsman]

Not helping with your conundrum, but I have a 5120 and love it. One thing though - you'll want to adjust the pickups to get them closer to the strings. Every one I've played in stores has the pickups set way, way too low!

' alt='>'>

[geek_usa]

I'd dump the seagull in a ditch somewhere.

Just make sure you tell me WHICH ditch!

[missedmyexit]

I'm wanting to pick up a Gretsch 5120 but need to sell something first. I have two acoustics and really need one only, so I am trying to decide which i should unload. I have an Epi J-200 and a Seagull S6. I like them both equally. The Epi despite being a laminate top plays AWESOME, and the Seagull is good as well. I'm TORN!!! Oh yeah, I have no case for the Seagull (Roadhouse gig bag) and I have a TKL hardshell case for the Epi which would probably make them equal as far as value i think.

 

 

I would sell the Epi but you described the Epi as Awesome and Seagull as 'good'. So I'm thinking you like your EPi better. So sell the Seagul.. To me .. For 2 dollars and Seventy-Five cents.

[Terry Allan Hall]

I'd be inclined to hang onto the Epi, myself...