Reply
Super Contributor
dboomer
Posts: 6,621
Registered: ‎05-01-2004

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

Toughts on the volume x feedback x monitoring question anyone?
It's the same for every speaker system. Until you get to the level where you cross the unity gain threshold you do not and will never have feedback. Once you turn up enough so that the ratio of the sound going into your mic from your mouth equals the sound going back into the mic from your speaker (regardless of what speaker you have) you will have feedback. It is always the ratio of those two levels
Don Boomer
Line 6, inc.
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
Posts: 5,335
Registered: ‎04-27-2006

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

The Bose and the sticks still seem to have the same foot print as a normal speaker stand, don't they? It doesn't seem that my powered speaker is any bigger than the stand legs' floor area. Can't see how a stick saves space. I'd be more likely to trip over the base/legs if the speaker didn't keep me in bounds.
This space intentionally left blank
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
Posts: 647
Registered: ‎07-01-2011

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

I've never seen so much negativity toward the fishstick. Kind of surprising. I was planning to buy one as soon as I knew what I'd be able to make.
Free prog-related metal from Michigan.

http://www.silentlapse.com
Please use plain text.
Moderator
daddymack
Posts: 37,591
Registered: ‎04-26-2003

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

I don't think it is negativity...just honest opinions. I like mine for what it is. I spent several months looking for something that would handle the basics, get the sound, be easy to haul, easy to set up, easy to use...the SA220, (compared to the acoustic guitar amps on he market Fender, Fishman, Acoustic, SWR, Marshall, Genz, etc. and the Bose Compact) seemed to fit my needs. John Bartus gigs his regularly, and he seems to like it. It may not suit everyone. It can't. But for what it is, and what it does, I am happy with mine. It is not going to work well in a noisy bar. I figured that out, but my goal is to not play in noisy bars. The negativity seems to come from people who are using it for purposes other than intended, or own something else. :wave:
We are currently experiencing some technical difficulties due to reality fluctuations. The elves are working tirelessly to patch the correct version of reality. Activities here have been temporarily disabled since the fundamentals of mathematics, physics and reason may be incomprehensible during this indeterminant period of instability. Normal service will be restored once we are certain as to what 'normal' is.

Save the earth. It's the only planet with dark chocolate, whiskey, and wine.

Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
Posts: 647
Registered: ‎07-01-2011

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

Yeah, negativity was a pretty strong word.
Free prog-related metal from Michigan.

http://www.silentlapse.com
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
Potts
Posts: 2,744
Registered: ‎05-01-2012

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

Sorry...my intention wasn't to try and turn this into a Bose thread...but then again I didn't bring it up. :smileywink:
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
Posts: 647
Registered: ‎07-01-2011

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

I am glad the knocks came up though because it sounds like if I were to try to mix in some piano I'd be sorely disappointed. Lack of bass is a complaint I all but ignore most of the time because usually it's made by people who don't value highs properly about fine sounding systems.
Free prog-related metal from Michigan.

http://www.silentlapse.com
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
Posts: 39,695
Registered: ‎02-18-2001

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

I don't think it is negativity...just honest opinions. I like mine for what it is. I spent several months looking for something that would handle the basics, get the sound, be easy to haul, easy to set up, easy to use...the SA220, (compared to the acoustic guitar amps on he market Fender, Fishman, Acoustic, SWR, Marshall, Genz, etc. and the Bose Compact) seemed to fit my needs.
John Bartus gigs his regularly, and he seems to like it.
It may not suit everyone.
It can't.
But for what it is, and what it does, I am happy with mine.
It is not going to work well in a noisy bar. I figured that out, but my goal is to not play in noisy bars.
The negativity seems to come from people who are using it for purposes other than intended, or own something else. :wave:


Much like driving all sizes of nails with a 16# sledge-hammer, it's easier to use the right tool for the job...no such thing as a PA system that's right for ALL acts/gigs.
http://acapella.harmony-central.com/...ds-is-OK/page2

Quote Originally Posted by Hoddy View Post
Best attention whoring thread ever!!!!

http://acapella.harmony-central.com/......&highlight=

Well done...you really had those idiots fooled!
Tired of the constant Harmony Central outages? Stay in touch at Melody Vine Forums
Please use plain text.
Contributor
Kevinlane
Posts: 68
Registered: ‎09-02-2006

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

I like mine.
Truer mids that other "stick" PAs
If it's feeding back you're too close to it. If you can't get far enough away, you're playing in a small enough room that it should work fine unless your're trying to over amplify the room. These are acoustic solo gigs, the sound shouldn't "dominate" but be very present.

Guys quit bitching about the low end! Anytime you add a kick drum(live or recorded) you just upped the ante, and need a different rig for a different game.
As far as bass through it, I think your crazy or lazy! I'm a pro bassist primarily, and no PA alone sounds best without a bass amp(at least the front end of one)
So bring your own little combo and play.

Remember it's a small , one trip, PA/Amp for a singing gtr player.
Try DropBox! click here to help me get more storage
http://db.tt/8euR2EGW
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
Potts
Posts: 2,744
Registered: ‎05-01-2012

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

These are acoustic solo gigs, the sound shouldn't "dominate" but be very present.
This could be another topic but I don't agree with that statement. I guess if we're sitting around playing Jack Johnson or James Taylor in a quiet setting, but that's not always the case. I'd say that over 75% of my gigs need some good solid volume.
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
donkey 12
Posts: 316
Registered: ‎03-06-2010

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

These are acoustic solo gigs, the sound shouldn't "dominate" but be very present.


What a generalization. I think most would agree that it depends on the type of venue/performance.
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
Posts: 648
Registered: ‎08-08-2005

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

Remember -- if you're just doing acoustic guitar and vocals, you can get some good solid volume out of the Fish Stick. If you're adding piano/keys, a bass, or a kick drum, the Fish Stick will not work. It was designed for the singing acoustic-electric guitar player -- nothing else! The four-letter word company (Bose) has designed versions of its L1 & L2 systems to be more full range; Lee Flier has used them for years with her rock band, and they seem to work fine for her. But anytime you try and push something past its engineered specs, you'll get results like crappy sound or blown drivers. Today's PA technology is a wonderful thing... used responsibly! :smileywink:
John Bartus
John Bartus & Storm Watch
Live From the Florida Keys
http://www.johnbartus.com
http://www.cdbaby.com/Artist/JohnBartus
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
Posts: 647
Registered: ‎07-01-2011

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

Anybody use it with drop tunings? Say an open C tuning? I like open tunings quite a bit.
Free prog-related metal from Michigan.

http://www.silentlapse.com
Please use plain text.
Moderator
daddymack
Posts: 37,591
Registered: ‎04-26-2003

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

Open G with the low D...it has no problem reproducing that...
We are currently experiencing some technical difficulties due to reality fluctuations. The elves are working tirelessly to patch the correct version of reality. Activities here have been temporarily disabled since the fundamentals of mathematics, physics and reason may be incomprehensible during this indeterminant period of instability. Normal service will be restored once we are certain as to what 'normal' is.

Save the earth. It's the only planet with dark chocolate, whiskey, and wine.

Please use plain text.
Contributor
Kevinlane
Posts: 68
Registered: ‎09-02-2006

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

This could be another topic but I don't agree with that statement. I guess if we're sitting around playing Jack Johnson or James Taylor in a quiet setting, but that's not always the case. I'd say that over 75% of my gigs need some good solid volume.
Dude, that statement has to do with the feedback someone said he's got with it. I have to WORK at it to get my SA220 to feedback! Once again, the typed word and missed nuances of those words, make a point harder to understand when it's made on a internet bb, than when it's made in a conversation.
Try DropBox! click here to help me get more storage
http://db.tt/8euR2EGW
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
Potts
Posts: 2,744
Registered: ‎05-01-2012

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

Dude, that statement has to do with the feedback someone said he's got with it. I have to WORK at it to get my SA220 to feedback! Once again, the typed word and missed nuances of those words, make a point harder to understand when it's made on a internet bb, than when it's made in a conversation.
Right on brother...I used to teach a lesson back in the day that described the "communication" process. The following are the approximate percentages for the entire communication process: Words- 7% Tone/pace- 38% Body Language- 55% No wonder nobody knows what the hell anyone is talking about on the internet- we're getting about 15% with emoticons :smileywink:
Please use plain text.
Frequent Contributor
GmanJeff
Posts: 112
Registered: ‎08-16-2007

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

I'm happy with mine. It sounds as if the OP's concern is whether the unit can be loud enough for his particular applications - that's a tough one to answer without trying one in those specific contexts. Maybe buy one from a vendor with a liberal return policy, and see how it does?
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
dparr
Posts: 33,261
Registered: ‎09-07-2005

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

I've used a Fishman SA 220 at my solo gigs several times and have been very impressed with it. I'm a Chapman Stick player so I play some very low notes. No, the bass does not make your teeth rattle but it has a very pleasant and even frequency response. In fact the Fishman has become a lot of Stick players go-to-amps.

BTW the Bose unit was not pleasing to my ear at all. I used one with two subs for about a year of weekly gigs at a place I played. It always seemed to be lacking something no matter how I set it. Not a fan at all.

I'd say go with the Fishman.
“One who loves & understands nature will never be alone & will never be afraid.”
-Rachel Carson-
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
Posts: 3,868
Registered: ‎05-02-2003

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

I've played a couple of gigs on the fishman. THey aren't bad.

I also own a couple of prx612 and would much rather bring one of those and a 4ch. notebook mixer ... IMO, it sounds more solid and feels better when getting louder. While I liked the compactness of the packing that it had, I think that I could put the anvil case I carry all my crap in (whcih is big enough for a small mixer) on top of one and dolly it in and be just as happy with the load in.

That said, if I was given a choice between showing up and seeing a fishamn and bringing my own, I always take the fishman. It's not bad, I just wouldn't want to own one.
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
rodclement
Posts: 1,871
Registered: ‎07-13-2007

Re: Fishman SA 220...yep! One more discussion on stick PA's!

I've ordered the fishman unit and will report on my toughts once I've used it a couple of times. Without going in circles to much, I would add that another huge positive for a stick system for me, is that it is non-impacting to the venue owners/managers/patrons. I have heard more than once, people complaining about volume before a band even starts playing just because the "speakers are so big". The fishman would be for those kind of venues, the Country Club setting...the quieter, more intimate restaurant, the place where patrons arrive and immedialty ask to seat away from the band even before they are playing because visualy they already made a decision of how loud you will be even before they heard you... The single stick pa creates the right visual impression, it is easy to set-up, easy to carry, and if it has suitable sound...well...one can only hope! :smileyhappy: Rod
www.tablefor2.net
Please use plain text.