Reply
Super Contributor
Posts: 3,914
Registered: ‎10-08-2006

Re: Is your recording / mix any good? Find out here!

Nice. Lacks mastering, but guess you know. Nice sounds and playing. Overall very well done. Thanks for recognizing that I'm lord over all :smileyhappy:
If you want to interpret it that way, I guess that's cool.
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
Posts: 1,373
Registered: ‎11-21-2008

Re: Is your recording / mix any good? Find out here!

Here's a mix of a theme I composed for a non-profit organization's money management podcast. Open to feedback as far as the mix goes, I just recently started getting into mixing and this is my first project I did myself from start to finish (composing, tracking, mixing, mastering). This was all done in Pro Tools 10- I used EZ Drummer for drums, captured the guitars and bass with my Duet, and got the synth sounds from the built in AIR synths (Xpand2 and Vacuum). Didn't do much along the lines of mastering besides using Waves' L2 Limiter to get the volume up to current standards.

http://soundcloud.com/nate-barnes/podcast-theme
Online Rhythm Section Tracks (Drums and Bass) Recorded In A Pro Studio:
http://backupband.net

Good dealings with: Sunsetcarcrash
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
Posts: 7,265
Registered: ‎12-04-2005

Re: Is your recording / mix any good? Find out here!

Hey guys, here is a mix of a rather heavy rock track. Vocals will be recorded by tomorrow but I put some work in this mix already. The song was recorded fully mic'd in a live take. Guitars and bass are okay for my taste but the kick and snare could still use some punch. Any tipps appreciated. http://soundcloud.com/we-are-rodha/bliss-v5d/s-g3A2V :wave:
LOOKING FOR:
BLUE BALL MICROPHONE
IRON ETHER PEDALS

//////////////////// . R O D H A
//////////////
/// . J U P I T E R . E F F E C T S
/////////////////////////
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
fakeplasticshrub
Posts: 386
Registered: ‎07-13-2001

Re: Is your recording / mix any good? Find out here!

Hey guys, here is a mix of a rather heavy rock track. Vocals will be recorded by tomorrow but I put some work in this mix already. The song was recorded fully mic'd in a live take. Guitars and bass are okay for my taste but the kick and snare could still use some punch. Any tipps appreciated. http://soundcloud.com/we-are-rodha/bliss-v5d/s-g3A2V :wave:
*a rather heavy rock track* these are the five words that will get me to listen to a song :smileyhappy: Well the guitar is right up the middle or a little to the right? and the snare appears to be on the left headphone a bit, maybe as a result of the positioning of the guitar to the right. I mean, it might be my headphones. Is this what you're going for? The guitar and bass merge really nicely as sounds, but it is weird to me to have all that come up the middle. I like the crack of the snare and the way it makes its way to the edge of the headphones. I like my snares in the middle, for which it's possible the overheads need a different panning, or it may be the other sounds taking away the snare from my right ear. Re the kick, often it's a question of putting little holes in the eqs of the bass and kick so they aren't treading on each other's sound too much, the bass definitely dominates out of the two on this one. A little 4k boost or so might bring out some more click, and cutting the bass wherever the kick is coming through on a frequency analyser. The snare could perhaps use a touch more body in the mid-range if you want it firmer, but it sits very nicely sound-wise for me, perhaps it's just not being hit too hard. Overall it's a cool song though, moody and mysterious with cool tone, I really like it!
http://deathapedisco.bandcamp.com/ --- Album streaming here
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
Posts: 7,265
Registered: ‎12-04-2005

Re: Is your recording / mix any good? Find out here!

Hey man, thanks a lot for taking the time to help me out. The snare is slightly to the left. I wanted it that way to achieve at least a little bit of spread since the guitar and bass is mainly centered. The right-sidedness of the guitar is a result of slightly different EQing the one live take track. So it might be psycho-acoustically. I reworked the kick and snare eversince I posted the link. I ended up finding a trick for the snare to sound how I wanted it and also improved on the kick. I sent the EQ to an aux channel, down pitched it and put a fully wet reverb on it. Blended in, it added that down-tuned, almost woordrim sound I aimed for. Here's the link to the current, almost final version of it, this time even with vocals :smileyhappy: http://soundcloud.com/we-are-rodha/bliss-voc-v2/s-WMCak Thanks again!
LOOKING FOR:
BLUE BALL MICROPHONE
IRON ETHER PEDALS

//////////////////// . R O D H A
//////////////
/// . J U P I T E R . E F F E C T S
/////////////////////////
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
Posts: 3,046
Registered: ‎10-26-2004

Re: Is your recording / mix any good? Find out here!

Hey man, thanks a lot for taking the time to help me out. The snare is slightly to the left. I wanted it that way to achieve at least a little bit of spread since the guitar and bass is mainly centered. The right-sidedness of the guitar is a result of slightly different EQing the one live take track. So it might be psycho-acoustically. I reworked the kick and snare eversince I posted the link. I ended up finding a trick for the snare to sound how I wanted it and also improved on the kick. I sent the EQ to an aux channel, down pitched it and put a fully wet reverb on it. Blended in, it added that down-tuned, almost woordrim sound I aimed for. Here's the link to the current, almost final version of it, this time even with vocals :smileyhappy: http://soundcloud.com/we-are-rodha/bliss-voc-v2/s-WMCak Thanks again!
i had the impression with the first version that the guitars overall too loud, but didn't post anything. now with the vocals i feel this even stronger. unless you want the vox in the back... and can't predict how it will come out when its mastered, if the vox will be after the compression much more in the front as they are now. i think the "clean" guitar is even more "louder". i would turn overall the guitar(s) a bit down, the clean part a bit more. it will still be very heavy, especially if you turn the volume up while listening, but it will not bury everything behind the guitars when the guitars are lowered it could also become necessary to lower the bass as well... just my thoughts, from another noob :smileyhappy:
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
fakeplasticshrub
Posts: 386
Registered: ‎07-13-2001

Re: Is your recording / mix any good? Find out here!

Hey man, thanks a lot for taking the time to help me out. The snare is slightly to the left. I wanted it that way to achieve at least a little bit of spread since the guitar and bass is mainly centered. The right-sidedness of the guitar is a result of slightly different EQing the one live take track. So it might be psycho-acoustically. I reworked the kick and snare eversince I posted the link. I ended up finding a trick for the snare to sound how I wanted it and also improved on the kick. I sent the EQ to an aux channel, down pitched it and put a fully wet reverb on it. Blended in, it added that down-tuned, almost woordrim sound I aimed for. Here's the link to the current, almost final version of it, this time even with vocals :smileyhappy: http://soundcloud.com/we-are-rodha/bliss-voc-v2/s-WMCak Thanks again!
noooo worries. It sounds really good, a very mono sparse feel, which works with the music, the new mix is great. Perhaps, as t_e_l_e says, the guitar could come down a touch, which might even allow the snare to come up a little, but that's all personal preference, main thing it sounds really good, like a man howling in a gale in the dead of night. I think. An Isis vibe with a twisted rock edge 3/4s through especially. Do you have a facebook page as a band? my turn, whole band demo of Death Ape Disco's title track (the *pop song*), with a free download no less, and I'm interested to know how people find it, as a song, a mix, everything http://soundcloud.com/death-ape-disco/death-ape-disco-new-demo If you like it please leave a comment or download or share, it looks all threadbare there! If you hate it, even better.
http://deathapedisco.bandcamp.com/ --- Album streaming here
Please use plain text.
Regular Contributor
Posts: 179
Registered: ‎10-07-2006

Re: Is your recording / mix any good? Find out here!

What does everyone think of these mixes? http://elephanthighway.bandcamp.com/album/we-made-this Edit: Mostly worried about the level and sound of the drums.
Please use plain text.
Frequent Contributor
frosty55
Posts: 135
Registered: ‎06-03-2008

Tell me what you think.

Here is a track from a complete CD of songs that have been mixed down for our singer to use as backing tracks for the finished mix. Spent ages just mixing the songs down of covers that we will put in our set.
Its just drums, bass and guitar that I taped on an 8 track machine with half inch analogue tape!
This track is the Free classic, "The Hunter".
Whats your thoughts on how this should be Eq d or even compressed?
Thanks.
http://soundcloud.com/dashboard
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
Posts: 1,917
Registered: ‎10-07-2007

Re: Is your recording / mix any good? Find out here!

What does everyone think of these mixes?
http://elephanthighway.bandcamp.com/album/we-made-this

Edit: Mostly worried about the level and sound of the drums.


LIstened to the first track. (Not on great speakers.) Good job.

My critique would be that the instruments didn't sound very coherent space-wise. That is they sounded like they were all over-dubbed in different rooms (or different reverb/ambience applied). I don't know if you were going for that intentionally.

I would have brought the horns down a bit and drums and bass up. Also, I think the guitar parts would have been more powerful with a bit less distortion, although that's a tracking issue rather than a mix issue.
http://www.thesymbols.net



http://www.jascoguitar.com







"Imagination is more important than knowledge." - Albert Einstein


Please use plain text.
Valued Contributor
ambient
Posts: 8,450
Registered: ‎09-14-2006

Re: Is your recording / mix any good? Find out here!

http://soundcloud.com/mysoapbox/waiting-first-mix I haven't really bothered trying to 'master' it, but I did put a limiter on the whole thing to catch the higher peaks and bring up the level. I doubt it's as loud as most commercial mixes though. This is the first track I've every mixed and also my first time singing/writing lyrics. Any suggestions on improving the mix?
The Pedal Builders of HCFX - Additions and corrections welcome.

Good trades & good people: jorhay1, Amplifier_Worship, Paint, devi
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
gubu
Posts: 8,347
Registered: ‎11-26-2006

Re: Is your recording / mix any good? Find out here!

[ Edited ]

ambient wrote:
http://soundcloud.com/mysoapbox/waiting-first-mix I haven't really bothered trying to 'master' it, but I did put a limiter on the whole thing to catch the higher peaks and bring up the level. I doubt it's as loud as most commercial mixes though. This is the first track I've every mixed and also my first time singing/writing lyrics. Any suggestions on improving the mix?

Love the song. The mix is pretty good - there are some things that jump out at me. Bear in mind that these critiques are usually wholly subjective!

I'd like to hear it without the limiter on there. It seems like the louder sections, the choruses and the outro, are too intense, too much limiting. Everything is a little bit too upfront during these sections.

Did you EQ some of the mix elements for presence, boosting the mids/hi-mids? That could also be the reason why it sounds a little too upfront. If you did EQ for maximum presence, I'd kill those EQ boosts on the guitars for starters.

 

Apart from that, the sonics are really good. Crystal clear, and importantly, a good song and a musical mix.

My only other suggestion might be to cut somewhere around 1000-1600Hz on the 'loudhailer' style vocals, and take them back 2 or 3 dB overall, perhaps turning up the reverb send as well (especially on the 'come back' lines @~2:20). That type of vocal effect needs quite a bit of reverb to sit in a mix properly, and probably some compression.

 

 

 

 

tafka mintparasol............


'When we live in a culture that really admires money, when that's your primary criterion for who's a good person, who's powerful and who's interesting, you really belittle the human spirit and what it means to be alive. But we tend to do that.'
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
nat whilk II
Posts: 2,259
Registered: ‎07-15-2005

Re: Is your recording / mix any good? Find out here!

Just my taste prolly but I don't care for that super-compressed snare sound. I do see how that sound works for metal, but in power-ballad stuff, it lacks "reality" to my ears.

Also - you hit the big crash in unison with the snare a lot, which is a standard thing, but the sampled crash is so repetitive, it gets a little obnoxious. I'd say vary up that crash with other samples or treatments that make it sound less like you just hit the "crash" button over and over.

The guitars sound nice. The vox needs to sit down a bit more into the mix as noticed by gubu. But good work - if it were my mix, I'd go listen to some good Tom Petty tracks and take a few hints from his most excellent mixes.

nat whilk ii
Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
gubu
Posts: 8,347
Registered: ‎11-26-2006

Re: Is your recording / mix any good? Find out here!

I've got one, and don't know where to go with it, besides getting better takes.

Sometimes I love the sound of this mix, and sometimes I hate it!

https://soundcloud.com/gubu/revelation-in-a


Anyone got any thoughts?

 

 

tafka mintparasol............


'When we live in a culture that really admires money, when that's your primary criterion for who's a good person, who's powerful and who's interesting, you really belittle the human spirit and what it means to be alive. But we tend to do that.'
Please use plain text.
Occasional Contributor
Connor Caswell
Posts: 11
Registered: ‎05-05-2013

Re: Is your recording / mix any good? Find out here!

I just started writing my new song so it will be a while till I post it up on the forum. But I must say it sounds badass and it is a entirely new creature all on its own. If it sounds awesome in production then it will sound just fantastic for the final product!! Can't wait!! Well better get back to writing!!

 

 

Please use plain text.
Contributor
Elliott Jeffries
Posts: 25
Registered: ‎04-19-2013

Re: Is your recording / mix any good? Find out here!


gubu wrote:

I've got one, and don't know where to go with it, besides getting better takes.

Sometimes I love the sound of this mix, and sometimes I hate it!

https://soundcloud.com/gubu/revelation-in-a


Anyone got any thoughts?

 

 


Just layer the voice so it fills up the song more. Right now it sits with the instruments, try duplicating the voice to left and right tracks, tweaking them a little with different proccessing. Have another layer of your voice that's in the background like a string section. Don't go overboard with the processing, just a dab of reverb, delay, chorus and etc to give it some color. Good song!

Please use plain text.
Super Contributor
gubu
Posts: 8,347
Registered: ‎11-26-2006

Re: Is your recording / mix any good? Find out here!


Elliott Jeffries wrote:

gubu wrote:

I've got one, and don't know where to go with it, besides getting better takes.

Sometimes I love the sound of this mix, and sometimes I hate it!

https://soundcloud.com/gubu/revelation-in-a


Anyone got any thoughts?

 

 


Just layer the voice so it fills up the song more. Right now it sits with the instruments, try duplicating the voice to left and right tracks, tweaking them a little with different proccessing. Have another layer of your voice that's in the background like a string section. Don't go overboard with the processing, just a dab of reverb, delay, chorus and etc to give it some color. Good song!


Thanks Elliot,

I'd actually forgotten I'd posted that here!

I will have to try that out. There is some parallel processing on the vocal, but it's all in mono.

Thanks for the kind words on the song :smileyhappy:

 

tafka mintparasol............


'When we live in a culture that really admires money, when that's your primary criterion for who's a good person, who's powerful and who's interesting, you really belittle the human spirit and what it means to be alive. But we tend to do that.'
Please use plain text.