here is what I did when I switched to electric guitar about 3 or 4 years ago :
- bought a strat because it was said to be the most versatile guitar : Fender American Series (800$ eBay). Couldn't set up the tremolo and intonation at that point. Played it a little bit and sold it.
- bought a Custom 72 Fender Telecaster. Theoretically versatile. MIJ (800$ eBay). Super neck and accurate intonation. Considered parting with it many times but it has a magic that makes me want to keep it every time I compare it to another. Shortcomings : dark sounding humbucker best for certain styles only.
- bought a Les Paul 60s tribute, 'cause it was said to be one of the best blues axe below 1000$ (paid 1200$ shipped actually). The nut was a bit weak. I ordered tools and material to make a proper bone nut. I made one and it's fantastic. Proud I am. Stays in tune. Sounds like a milion bucks with creamy P90 pickups. Doesn't get much playing though. Will probably keep it for a very long time. Even though I am into thicker necks now.
- deals I couldn't pass by on strats : Highway one + 50th American Series. Watched Karl Vereheyen's video on Youtube about tremolo setup. I managed to set up the strats properly. They play like a dream. Didn't like the wider string spacing on the early H1, sold it. The 50th doesn't get much playing at the moment but it's one of the best non custom shop ash strat. As long as finance allow I'll keep it around.
- found a nice 90s Gibson SG special in a pawn shop nearby (500$). My first HH guitar. Nicely balanced, thicker neck. That's when I found that my hands get less fatigue with thicker necks.
- got a great deal on Squier 50s Classic Vibe Strat. Set it up well. Definitely a keeper. You can't beat it for 200$ used.
- etc.
My point is : building a nice collection of used/bargain iconic guitars in the 200-1000$ range was the only way for me to actually find out for myself what the guitars feel and sound like. Some will stay, some have gone. If storage space and finances allow for, why not go down that path ? I'd recommend starting with hardtails, just a few ideas :
- Epiphone 339 (small bodied semi-hollow with splittable buckers)
- Squier Classic 50s Vibe Telecaster or Baja Telecaster
- Squier Stratocaster (either Vintage Modified or Classic Vibe)
- American Strat/Tele
- Gibson SG (epiphones are often neck heavy)
- Gibson Les Paul / Epiphone Les Paul Plus Top / Epiphone Custom Les Paul
To sum up, I'd get iconic stuff (good resale value) at a bargain price (used or discount).
Personally, I think extremely expensive guitars are for people who know exactly what they need in terms of tone, ergonomics and looks. I don't regret any day having a variety of decent to excellent guitars rather than one or two Custom Shop Items which I would be worried for any time they get played (dents, fret wear when practicing awckward bends, etc.)
Getting a new guitar every 6 months is a pleasure too...
"The blues is the recognition of a tragedy, and the optimism to deal with it" (Fruteland Jackson)
"You may think you're playing your instrument, but what you're really playing is the audience" (anonymous)