
Originally Posted by
Phil O'Keefe
I'm just curious. If you played an instrument when you were in school (or still do), what was it? Did you enjoy it? Do you still have your old band instrument (whatever it was)?
Me - I started out on clarinet (my brother still has it last time I checked) when I was in junior high school, and quickly switched over to sax. I added guitar, piano and bass while in high school, but it was mainly the reeds that I played in the school bands - concert / orchestral, marching and jazz / stage band.
How about you?

I don't know if this counts, but my best friend and I took a guitar class in High School. We already knew how to play, but we wanted to learn more.
Unfortunately, the class was just a basic beginner's class teaching stuff we already knew. So we quickly tired of it.
There was one kid who sat in front of us. The only riff he knew how to play was the riff from "Smoke On The Water". He played it every day. My friend and I got so fed up hearing that riff, that we tied him to his chair. He stopped playing it after that!
The teacher of the class was the Band Director at our High School. He could see that we were bored, so he challenged us to take a Music Theory class that he taught.
My friend and I did not read music at that time. Besides, we thought music theory was only for band geeks. All the people taking the class were kids who had been playing instruments most of their lives, and who already knew how to read music.
We ended up signing up for Music Theory. It was the hardest, but most rewarding class that I ever took in school. It taught me about harmony, melody and rhythm, and has been essential in making me a good songwriter. I had to work twice as hard as the rest of the class to catch up with them, so I burned the midnight oil at home studying the text. I didn't do that for any of my other classes, but I ended up on the honor roll anyway, on the strength of my good memory.
But I enjoyed the hard work. For our final exam, we had to write out a horn chart. I played all the parts on my piece of shit acoustic guitar at home, and notated it on music paper. I was arranging parts for instruments that I had never played.
It must have been good, because I got an "A" in that class.
I wonder to this day what my horn arrangement sounded like when it was actually played by a real horn section!
I only play MANLY pedals!