
Originally Posted by
1001gear
Pretty good rhythmic display I think. Takes musical knowledge and considerable instrumental proficiency. See from this perspective your stars just make heat and bad smell. Uh, burnt rubber bad smell. lol
I probably shouldn't get into things like this, but I think you're kind of full of it, man. I took the time to watch a good few minutes of Hale and the entire Caplette vid you posted, and I don't really see much of a difference where instrumental proficiency is concerned. You also have to consider that they're playing to two different styles of music to two different audiences and that the Hale vid is doesn't provide as good a viewing angle to really see what he's doing.
Hale's playing didn't really wow me, but I'd definitely say he's very solid drummer with more tricks up his sleeve than most in that genre. Caplette, OTOH, is perhaps a slightly more technically capable drummer (goes with the style of music), but I find her lacking in consistency and other elements of "solidness." Sloppy ghost notes and rolls, and while you might not like how Hale flails away at his kit (most fans of that music do, though), she doesn't even hit her toms hard enough to get a decent sound out of them half of the time. She also missed a drum at one point, don't think I heard that out of Hale. I'm not trying to down her, she's a good drummer. Just making a point here.
Soundcreation is right with the subjective angle (it took me some time to learn this, as some of you might recall), but even where pure technicality is concerned, I don't think you have much of an argument.