Harmony Central Forums
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.

Tom Anderson vs. Suhr: Let's start the year with a debate!

Collapse



X
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #91






    Quote Originally Posted by fretless
    View Post

    An instrument / luthier company ?




    yeah.
    MarkWein.com and Forums
    Study with me on Truefire.com!
    McFeely Custom Guitars Artist

    Comment


    • #92






      Quote Originally Posted by Mark Wein
      View Post

      yeah.




      Cool , All the best to him and yeah details when it happens !
      "Our virtues and our failings are inseparable, like force and matter. When they separate, man is no more."
      Nikola Tesla

      Comment


      • #93






        Quote Originally Posted by fretless
        View Post

        Cool , All the best to him and yeah details when it happens !






        will do! I'm pretty excited about it and I think he'll do a great job...I'm just a very impatient person, even after ordering two Suhrs
        MarkWein.com and Forums
        Study with me on Truefire.com!
        McFeely Custom Guitars Artist

        Comment


        • #94
          Haven't played either and probably never will. I think that they look fantastic and I've heard great examples of both in the hands of gifted players. If I was shopping right now and had to pick it would probably be a Suhr because I like some of their configurations better, but if I had two of the exact same designs to choose from in front of me I'd have to pick which one jived with me better.



          So basically I provided no useful information. I do think that it's funny when people judge something based on zero personal experience or a very limited sample pool.
          AxeFXII with these: Axis | BMG RS | Strat |N4| LP Classic | SG Classic | Sheraton | Tele

          Comment


          • #95






            Quote Originally Posted by Steadfastly
            View Post

            Skip, that wasn't a fair test and you used different amps for the two guitars. I liked the $250.00 PRS on three and one was tied with the Anderson but to be fair, you need to have the same song, same amp, same settings, etc. to be able to compare. I agree that most of the tone is in the amp, though. And, BTW, nice playing!




            Here you go. It's as close to apples & apples as I can get.



            Tom Anderson clips:

            http://www.soundclick.com/bands/defa...songID=5085428



            PRS Santana SE clip:



            http://www.soundclick.com/bands/defa...songID=5085346
            My Amps & Guitars:
            The Bassmen: Proud Fender Bassman Player
            Fender Blackface Fraternity Lifetime Member

            http://www.soundclick.com/bands/defa...&content=music

            Comment


            • #96
              I'd just go Carvin, too

              Comment


              • #97






                Quote Originally Posted by axegrinder
                View Post

                Well this sounds like a great topic for the next HCEG Argument Thread Series.



                What you say sounds easy on paper...if you use the same magnets, bobbins, base plates, wire, and same number of winds you should have the same result. But as Smorg's logic explains, if it was that easy, none of the hand makers would survive. I won't even touch why that is the case. It has no bearing on the Suhr vs Anderson debate.




                How do you know they don't? You might be surprised if you took apart the coils and looked at them. Of course, no one is going to go to that expense on their own just to prove a point and sure as snow is white the manufacturers are not going to tell you. They want everyone to think that their brand is the best. Am I cynical? Yes. I've been around awhile and have been fed a lot of baloney even by companies that I worked for. How many parts are there in a coil anyway? There's not that many different ways of building them that they are all that different except for the number of winds and the winding pattern.
                Foul language is the sign of a weak mind trying to express itself forcibly. * Thankfully, my computer program masks all the foul language and changes it to @&%)7#

                Comment


                • #98




                  I think the better brains is...are your brains a brains?





                  Now that we've had our bit of corksniffery, can we get back to important questions like: Agile or Xaviere?





                  You have the right to free speech, as long as you're not dumb enough to actually try it. -- Joe Strummer

                  Comment


                  • #99






                    Quote Originally Posted by Steadfastly
                    View Post

                    How do you know they don't? You might be surprised if you took apart the coils and looked at them. Of course, no one is going to go to that expense on their own just to prove a point and sure as snow is white the manufacturers are not going to tell you. They want everyone to think that their brand is the best. Am I cynical? Yes. I've been around awhile and have been fed a lot of baloney even by companies that I worked for. How many parts are there in a coil anyway? There's not that many different ways of building them that they are all that different except for the number of winds and the winding pattern.






                    I look forward to your forthcoming line of pickups.



                    If it was as easy as you say it is then there would be many more people making them. The fact is, I know people who have made guitars but none of them have made their pickups.
                    President and CEO of The Foundation Of Right
                    Also President and CEO of The Foundation Of Wrong






                    Originally Posted by StankNasty


                    the dream isn't in your parents' basement

                    Comment








                    • Quote Originally Posted by smorgdonkey
                      View Post

                      I look forward to your forthcoming line of pickups.




                      Will you do the marketing for me? Regards, Steadfastly
                      Foul language is the sign of a weak mind trying to express itself forcibly. * Thankfully, my computer program masks all the foul language and changes it to @&%)7#

                      Comment








                      • Quote Originally Posted by smorgdonkey
                        View Post

                        I look forward to your forthcoming line of pickups.



                        If it was as easy as you say it is then there would be many more people making them. The fact is, I know people who have made guitars but none of them have made their pickups.




                        I know a dude that did. Bryan, something or other.. Pickups ain't rocket science. They're fairly simple devices. It's the minutia that sets great builders apart from everyone else.
                        Signature...

                        Comment


                        • Metallurgy is materials science , you can use what is already made for you or you can make your own Like Seymour Duncan if you have the skill .
                          "Our virtues and our failings are inseparable, like force and matter. When they separate, man is no more."
                          Nikola Tesla

                          Comment








                          • Quote Originally Posted by LesPaulFetish
                            View Post

                            Took a look; do they all have zero frets?




                            Yes they do, but if that worries you, not to bother. You do not even know it is there.
                            Two of the nicest gentlemen, and most talented people: Mssr's Diezel and Krampe.
                            Je préfèrerais mourir sans un sou dans une rue en Europe que de vivre en Amérique sous l'administration actuelle. Alizée est la meilleure. Vous, les princesses pop américaines, n'avez aucun talent, aucune classe, et vous sonnez comme de la merde. Sarkozy et le reste de l'Europe se moquent de notre président dans son dos.

                            Comment








                            • Quote Originally Posted by mosiddiqi
                              View Post

                              They're both great guitars, I prefer the Suhr..just a feel thing..here's a quick vid with my S4 I did this morning..just warming up wankage






                              http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sAqRFWcKS68




                              Thanks for the video. Guitar looks nice as hell.









                              Quote Originally Posted by xrleroyx
                              View Post

                              I've always wanted a Suhr. Anderson's don't appeal to me but I'd give one a go. I don't think I deserve either yet. I plan on buying a very nice guitar within the next few years but honestly, I don't think I could really use it to its full potential.




                              HAHA! I agree. My playing skill is Fender MIM, but hey we can all wish for stuff that's better than us!









                              Quote Originally Posted by rock-lobster
                              View Post

                              Let me translate. I think music can have plenty of soul. A guitar, hell no. It either sounds good for what you do or it doesn't, and in either case it's your call how much soul you put into the music from there. I just can't stand when people say something like "it played and sounded good but had no mojo." IMO if it played and sounded good it's you who has no mojo




                              I agree with Rock. Soul, vibe, mojo is not in the instrument, it's in the individual. If you gave me a Santana PRS right now and gave Santana my Squier, I promise he will have much better soul and mojo than I will.









                              Quote Originally Posted by smorgdonkey
                              View Post

                              I think it comes down to being inspired by the feeling of the instrument in your hands. So, like most other things guitar-related, it comes down to personal preference.





                              Pickups are not easy to replicate. Ask anyone who has ever made a set. Ask Jason Lollar what he thinks...ask Bryan Gunsher if he thinks his product could be 'easily replicated' or Jim Wagner. Maybe Lindy Fralin. Ask them all and report back with what you find.



                              ...and finally, IF pickups were easily replicated, I'd have no brand name pickups at all because they would have been replicated by the companies that sell them cheap and I would have bought them all from there.




                              Of course pickups are easy to replicate. Drop a set of GFS into your Squier and it will sound like Fender Custom Shop









                              Quote Originally Posted by mosiddiqi
                              View Post

                              Thanks! ...look, I have a Squier Classic Vibe 60's Strat that I like a lot too, and my main guitar for years has been a Fender USA Standard..nothing particularly fancy there. But, there are a number of details on the Suhr that just make it work best for me. Apart from the excellent hardware and electrics (which could all be modded for sure on a cheaper guitar), there is the compound radius neck (again, if I was building a parts-caster from scratch, this is easy enough)..but the hardest thing to quantify is the "feel"....the Suhr just "feels" better than anything else I've played. For me, it has TONS of what people call "mojo"...but you might pick it up and think "what's the big deal?..it's just a nice Strat".



                              Price wise, in the UK, it cost about the same as a lower end Fender Custom shop..and frankly, was in a different class to any of those I tried..much more resonant and lively sounding. That's why I bought it.




                              I have always felt that when you pay a high price tag for a quality instruments, it's the feel that separates that instrument from the rest. In all honesty, finding great feel is not easy, and it does not come cheap. No matter how much I might mod my Squier, it will always feel heavy and clunky.





                              So to take it a step further, do you guys think a MIA Fender Deluxe would be the "poor man's" version of a Tom Anderson classic or Suhr S-Style guitar? $1500 for the Fender is certainly much cheaper and more realistic than $2100-$2300 for a Suhr/Tom Anderson. But does the MIA come close to giving you what the Suhr and Tom Anderson give? Playability? Feel? Quality of wood? 1-piece body? etc.
                              "Man who stand on toilet seat is high on pot"

                              The Squier Army
                              The "Official" Stratocaster Club


                              2010 Gisbon Les Paul Studio
                              2001 Fender Fat Strat
                              1997 Squire Strat Project

                              Blackstar HT1RH w/ 1x12 Eminence Cab

                              Boss ME-50
                              Whammy IV -> Vox 847 Wah ->TS9 -> Phase 90 -> DigiDelay -> Boss GE7 EQ

                              Good Transactions: PunkKitty, MetalGuitar08, conky

                              Comment


                              • By the way, for what's it worth, I like the Tom Anderson headstock and logo much more than the Suhr. Therefore, with no experience, and never having even touched one of these guitars, I proclaim Tom Anderson to THE BEST! haha
                                "Man who stand on toilet seat is high on pot"

                                The Squier Army
                                The "Official" Stratocaster Club


                                2010 Gisbon Les Paul Studio
                                2001 Fender Fat Strat
                                1997 Squire Strat Project

                                Blackstar HT1RH w/ 1x12 Eminence Cab

                                Boss ME-50
                                Whammy IV -> Vox 847 Wah ->TS9 -> Phase 90 -> DigiDelay -> Boss GE7 EQ

                                Good Transactions: PunkKitty, MetalGuitar08, conky

                                Comment









                                Working...
                                X