Harmony Central Forums
Announcement Announcement Module
Collapse
No announcement yet.

Does more gear equal more talent?

Page Title Module
Move Remove Collapse









X
Conversation Detail Module
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Does more gear equal more talent?

    A friend and I believe that it can, but for different reasons. I'll quickly outline the story to better understand where we're both coming from. He considers himself a "long time player", because we both got lessons at the age of eleven. He forgets that I started learning six years before that. And since I have no real social obligations anymore, I tend to hang out on my computer all day generally studying techniques and styles, along with about three to four hours practice a day. He believes that he only needs to see the technique once or see the tab once before he's ready to practice it for about fifteen minutes, then he's "mastered it". I wish I had comparison clips for you, but he keeps forgetting to record them for me.

    So then, my reasoning:
    I tend to buy guitars now based on the genres I associate them with. If they meet with the genre I want to learn, I buy it. For example, a HSH Ibanez is for metal, a SSS Strat is for blues and cleans, a LP type is for rockin' and buttery lead work. I take a very basic view on guitars-for-genres because it simplifies things for me. I can easily translate these skills onto other guitars, but generally I get the sounds I want from my basic views. When I have the sound, I get to practising. Then, obviously, I improve.

    His reasoning:
    He believes that the more gear he has and the better the quality of it (i.e. how much it's worth or how much it cost), the better his sound will be. The better the sound, the more he can get away with. For example, speedy, accurate lead work can be sloppy so long as there's enough distortion to hide it. Chord work can be sloppy so long as there's a good amount of reverb (which I don't quite understand), and cleans can be sloppy so long as there's a large use of effects like chorus, flange, delay etc etc.

    So to me, having more gear made me a better player, even if it was an unnecessary expense. I suppose if I didn't have such particular standards about tone in different genres, I could learn them all on one guitar. To me, it's about being inspired to learn the different styles by the instrument used. So I suppose it's equal parts image and tonal ability of the instrument. A flawed perception, but ultimately effective.

    What are your thoughts and opinions?
    Originally Posted by Fork Man


    The answer is, of course, onions.









    Originally Posted by MyNameIsMok...


    Blasphemer! I'll bite your nipples off.









    Originally Posted by nicholai


    All guitars suck. Except for mine. They rock.

  • #2
    he's doing it wrong.
    The Common Sense Mets Fan

    There is a cult of ignorance in the United States, and there always has been. The strain of anti-intellectualism has been a constant thread winding its way through our political and cultural life, nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that "my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge." - Isaac Asimov, Newsweek (21 January 1980)

    Comment


    • #3
      To be fair to him, having more guitars did make him practice a little more
      Originally Posted by Fork Man


      The answer is, of course, onions.









      Originally Posted by MyNameIsMok...


      Blasphemer! I'll bite your nipples off.









      Originally Posted by nicholai


      All guitars suck. Except for mine. They rock.

      Comment


      • #4
        I could buy an Indy car, but I won't win the race.
        Sure, you want gear that inspires, but like the old saw says: "A poor workman blames his tools."

        EG
        We're not in Kansas anymore.

        Comment


        • #5
          I could buy an Indy car, but I won't win the race.
          Sure, you want gear that inspires, but like the old saw says: "A poor workman blames his tools."

          EG


          You could buy an Indy car and practice, and you'll do better in the race than if you were to use a tractor

          I get what you mean, though. Taking the "one right tool" approach isn't exactly cost effective, nor is it totally necessary. But the results are what I wanted.

          Also, I probably should've used better wording. I'm interested to hear other people's stories
          Originally Posted by Fork Man


          The answer is, of course, onions.









          Originally Posted by MyNameIsMok...


          Blasphemer! I'll bite your nipples off.









          Originally Posted by nicholai


          All guitars suck. Except for mine. They rock.

          Comment


          • #6
            I learned 85% of what I know on one acoustic and one electric guitar, and was pretty good before I had the luxury of matching guitars to genres or tones. I have pretty well every tone under the sun covered now, at least for my purposes. Certain types of guitars will definitely make it easier to cop a particular vibe, as a Strat will for playing Hendrix-y blues licks. It took me a long time to understand why my HH Ibanez wouldn't sound like a Strat when I started into Little Wing.


            I don't agree with your friend. Having more and better gear will more than likely show up one's weaknesses, than mask them. The only benefit I can see is superficial; people will assume one knows what one's doing based upon the quality and quantity of his gear, but I've known people with lots more than I have, who can barely string together a 30 second pentatonic solo.
            "The Philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it."

            Karl Marx

            Comment


            • #7
              Sloppy playing can be heard through distortion and chorus.

              I don't believe tone is totally "in the fingers".....The Joe Satriani clip of him playing in the fan's basement with a ****************ty guitar and even ****************tier amp are easily enough to prove that to me.....A great guitar with a nice warm round tone through a nice amp with balanced frequencies will sound great with anyone who can properly fret a note and pluck a string.

              But having said that......all the great gear in the world isn't going to make your friend sound any better if he can't play well.

              And yeah.....different guitars can inspire different creative things....I do agree totally with that.

              Comment


              • #8
                Either you have the talent, the drive, ambition, motivation and opportunity to practice and play or you don't.

                I believe gear hording to be a dissorder/sickness which hinders us from bettering our guitar playing abilities.

                I am very sickly.
                Geezer Brigade Trooper #30
                1st generation Irish

                Comment


                • #9
                  I don't agree with your friend. Having more and better gear will more than likely show up one's weaknesses, than mask them. The only benefit I can see is superficial; people will assume one knows what one's doing based upon the quality and quantity of his gear, but I've known people with lots more than I have, who can barely string together a 30 second pentatonic solo.


                  This is quite accurate.
                  Got Funk?

                  Good deals with: wilsoneffectsll, mr cheef, the.nameless, kpd78, Seano_Porno, jonPhillips, gjhardwick, Korgi

                  Selling: PRICE DROP!! NEED TO SELL ASAP
                  AMT Japanese Girl WH-1
                  Zoom Multistomp
                  Digitech RP3 Blue version
                  Wilson Effects Uber Fubar Bliss


                  want to buy:
                  EHX Ring Thing
                  Devi Ever Hyperion
                  Orange Crush The Button Wampler.
                  BAT Pharaoh

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Having more gear never equals more talent.
                    “One who loves & understands nature will never be alone & will never be afraid.”
                    -Rachel Carson-

                    Comment


                    • #11


                      I don't agree with your friend. Having more and better gear will more than likely show up one's weaknesses, than mask them. The only benefit I can see is superficial; people will assume one knows what one's doing based upon the quality and quantity of his gear, but I've known people with lots more than I have, who can barely string together a 30 second pentatonic solo.


                      This thought had occurred to myself and other musical friends. But we kept it to ourselves in case we were just being dicks. But... The more gear he gets, the more it looks that way. The last time we "jammed" together (read: I played, he watched), I was using four guitars (Ibanez RG, Washburn KC, oddball with Les Paul tones and a CV sounding Squier Strat), with a 4040 multi-effects and a Kustom 2x12" amp. Naturally, I changed guitars and effects depending on what I was jamming. When he eventually did play, he used one guitar (his most expensive: Ibanez RGA32, HH active pickups) and a Laney 4x12" cab with Laney head. No effects, just huge amounts of distortion and reverb, no matter what the vibe. Needless to say, regardless of the vibe it sounded awful.

                      With regard to our amps... Sure, his is most certainly better than mine. But we're bedroom rockers for the most part. And when I play gigs, I use an even smaller amp.
                      Originally Posted by Fork Man


                      The answer is, of course, onions.









                      Originally Posted by MyNameIsMok...


                      Blasphemer! I'll bite your nipples off.









                      Originally Posted by nicholai


                      All guitars suck. Except for mine. They rock.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Eh, no reason to put that much thought into it. Some people are really inspired by having or acquiring more and better gear - nicer guitars, big amps, a huge effects board - and likely play better as a result. Others, myself included, are just fine practicing 'naked'. How somebody else chooses to play is no skin off my nose - I just do what inspires me.
                        I'm in a band called Little Sluggers. Signature.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Eh, no reason to put that much thought into it. Some people are really inspired by having or acquiring more and better gear - nicer guitars, big amps, a huge effects board - and likely play better as a result. Others, myself included, are just fine practicing 'naked'. How somebody else chooses to play is no skin off my nose - I just do what inspires me.


                          Good post, bro. Very understanding
                          I suppose to anyone that's familiar with my posts, it's fairly obvious that I over-think everything... It's a combination of nothing better to do and that reality at face value makes no sense to me
                          Originally Posted by Fork Man


                          The answer is, of course, onions.









                          Originally Posted by MyNameIsMok...


                          Blasphemer! I'll bite your nipples off.









                          Originally Posted by nicholai


                          All guitars suck. Except for mine. They rock.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            I agree with Poolshark. There is certainly an adult diaper in this..that is it Depends. Getting an expensive piece of gear just to show how much money you have probably won't. But getting something that inspires you clearly will.
                            Originally Posted by Frets99
                            I held one note through the whole thing and grimaced like I was being taken from behind by a camel.....



                            Member MAZI BEE KICK ASS MILITIA
                            HCGB #251
                            Guitars: F15 Fender Acoustic, F385 Takamine 12 String Acoustic, MIM Fender Strat with BG V60's, MIK Fender Blackout Tele with BG Pure90s, Reverend Manta Ray
                            Amps: Mesa TA-15, White Box 1x12 cab, Crate V18 1-12
                            Some Pedals

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Seems like both of you are overly concerned with gear.
                              This space intentionally left blank

                              Comment



                              Working...
                              X