Harmony Central Forums
Announcement Announcement Module
Collapse
No announcement yet.

Singing Pet Peeves.... what are yours?

Page Title Module
Move Remove Collapse









X
Conversation Detail Module
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Singing Pet Peeves.... what are yours?

    My biggest singing pet peeve is when a band fails to recognize the difference between the vocal instrument and the other instruments like guitars.

    Example... Song that will sound better in the singer's "pocket" vocal range, but the musicians don't want to learn it in another key. It's a heck of alot easier to use a capo or a different fingering than it is for a vocalist to sing a song that's too low or on the top edge of their vocal range for an extended time.

    Also, with respect for the pace of the show, it's a necessary evil to mix up the set list to allow "lighter" vocal songs after really tough songs.


    Bandmates keeping an open mind about these things helps them in the long run because they're not replacing their singer after 6 months because they've worn out their voice.
    Baimun's big Pickup Clearance on Ebay

  • #2
    Axl Rose.
    Selwonk.

    Comment


    • #3
      Axl Rose.



      Oh come on.







      I said "singing".
      Baimun's big Pickup Clearance on Ebay

      Comment


      • #4
        Oh come on.







        I said "singing".



        Selwonk.

        Comment


        • #5
          I shouldn't say that too loud or Ron won't ever talk to me again.

          Baimun's big Pickup Clearance on Ebay

          Comment


          • #6
            My biggest singing pet peeve is when a band fails to recognize the difference between the vocal instrument and the other instruments like guitars.

            Example... Song that will sound better in the singer's "pocket" vocal range, but the musicians don't want to learn it in another key. It's a heck of alot easier to use a capo or a different fingering than it is for a vocalist to sing a song that's too low or on the top edge of their vocal range for an extended time.
            What's wrong with working hard expanding your range. Your guitar player has spent thousands of hours practicing learing to play as fast as he need to be to be able to pull it off.

            All singers can expand their range, there is no such thing as a pocket vocal range.

            Comment


            • #7
              What's wrong with working hard expanding your range. Your guitar player has spent thousands of hours practicing learing to play as fast as he need to be to be able to pull it off.

              All singers can expand their range, there is no such thing as a pocket vocal range.


              None of us are superman dude. Besides that most of us don't make a living doing this and while some do I'd still be pressed to agrre that most can improve their range so that it can cover ALL the ground musically. Where's all the 7 octave singers? There are none.

              Comment


              • #8
                What's wrong with working hard expanding your range. Your guitar player has spent thousands of hours practicing learing to play as fast as he need to be to be able to pull it off.

                All singers can expand their range, there is no such thing as a pocket vocal range.


                One can expand one's vocal range but only to a point. Also, after a certain age, even that is nigh impossible.
                In short, your comment was stupid.
                My MYSPACE Page

                My Soundclick Page

                My YouTube Stuff

                Comment


                • #9
                  What's wrong with working hard expanding your range. Your guitar player has spent thousands of hours practicing learing to play as fast as he need to be to be able to pull it off.

                  All singers can expand their range, there is no such thing as a pocket vocal range.


                  Prediction:

                  At some point a singer will buy you a capo... and you'll look at it like "what's that for?"

                  Baimun's big Pickup Clearance on Ebay

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    My biggest singing pet peeve is when a band fails to recognize the difference between the vocal instrument and the other instruments like guitars.

                    Example... Song that will sound better in the singer's "pocket" vocal range, but the musicians don't want to learn it in another key. It's a heck of alot easier to use a capo or a different fingering than it is for a vocalist to sing a song that's too low or on the top edge of their vocal range for an extended time.

                    Also, with respect for the pace of the show, it's a necessary evil to mix up the set list to allow "lighter" vocal songs after really tough songs.


                    Bandmates keeping an open mind about these things helps them in the long run because they're not replacing their singer after 6 months because they've worn out their voice.
                    Sorry if this sounds jerkish, but as a guitarist I have a pet peeve about singers wanting to sing songs outside the original key, and just expecting the players to follow along no matter what. For guitar-centric tunes, sometimes this works and sometimes it doesn't.

                    Sure, a guitar player can capo a tune in C up to C# with no problems, but if the singer wants to take it down to Bb and there are a lot of embellishments involving open C and G chords, it's a completely different story.

                    Also, God help the singer who insists on key changes and then gets impatient on stage when you are fumbling around with a capo and trying to tune your guitar, or tuning the whole thing down to Eb or D.
                    Originally Posted by requiem156


                    Dokken has no album called Storm of Dragons. If they did, the songs would all be about this one dragon who got his heart broken by a mean female dragon. The riffs and solos would be killing, though.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Sorry if this sounds jerkish, but as a guitarist I have a pet peeve about singers wanting to sing songs outside the original key, and just expecting the players to follow along no matter what. For guitar-centric tunes, sometimes this works and sometimes it doesn't....

                      ....Also, God help the singer who insists on key changes and then gets impatient on stage when you are fumbling around with a capo and trying to tune your guitar, or tuning the whole thing down to Eb or D.


                      You don't sound jerkish at all. Just being aware of all the bandmembers needs and preferences can be enough to come to amicable adjustments.

                      Changing keys live would piss me off too. Sometimes the muscle memory takes over and you end up sliding to where you're used to... and over thinking what key you're in kills the spontenaity.

                      I'm mostly referring to rehearsed key changes that make the entire group sound more in-the-pocket, both in lead and harmony vocals.
                      Baimun's big Pickup Clearance on Ebay

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        7-strings, FTW.

                        Seriously, I'm mainly a singer, but as you can tell by my moniker, I'm also a guitar player, and if I'm accompanying someone else while they sing? I do everything to accomodate that singer, and I'll go as far as transposing on the fly if I have to.

                        So what if I make a couple of clams on the guitar? That's MUCH less of a distraction to the audience than if the singer sounds like crap through the entire song, in a key that's out of his or her range.

                        Just my opinion. Flame on...
                        My Prog-Metal Solo Project

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          "Fake" vibrato like The Bee Gees and Kenny Rogers.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            1: Whitney-like vocal gymnastics/wanking.

                            2: Patty Smith.
                            ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
                            Originally Posted by MattACaster : *Runs 2 blocks down the street to Guitar Center, grabs detuned Schecter off the wall, plugs into Line6 Spider and proceeds to bring teh brootalz*

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              One can expand one's vocal range but only to a point. Also, after a certain age, even that is nigh impossible.
                              Again, this is just another myth. Of course there is a limit to anything, but unless you are a man singing way in the soprano area you have a lot of potential.

                              When you start off bodybuilding being skinny and 60 kg you simply can't have the attitude that you'd might gain a couple of kg. Then you'll just be the one of many who confirm the myth that it's "impossible" to make a Hulk out of a wimp.

                              You need the spirit and attitude, go for it!!

                              If you don't believe me, buy Jaimie Venderas "Raise your voice", read it and work for it a while. Any man, bass or baritone can sing above a high powerful tenor C using the correct technique. Straining won't get you there. Correct practice will.

                              I know, cause I used to stran with a E (as in open thin e-string on guitar), now I sing AC/DC tunes. I will be 40 soon and keep singing higher and louder....

                              But most people want to believe what you said, cause it's so much more comfortable to not work hard....

                              Comment



                              Working...
                              X